Arch Manning vs. Quinn Ewers: The Quarterback Showdown Shaking Up Longhorn Nation
The Texas Longhorns football program has always been synonymous with star power and high expectations.
As the team reflects on a bittersweet season ending in a College Football Playoff semifinal loss to Ohio State, a new debate is brewing in Austin: who should be the starting quarterback for the Longhorns in 2025—veteran Quinn Ewers or rising star Arch Manning?
The Case for Quinn Ewers
Quinn Ewers, a former five-star recruit and transfer from Ohio State, has proven himself as a reliable leader on the field. In the 2024 season, Ewers passed for over 3,000 yards and led the Longhorns to their first playoff appearance in years.
His experience, poise under pressure, and familiarity with Steve Sarkisian’s offense make him a strong candidate to remain the starter.
Ewers’ performance in the semifinal—283 passing yards with two touchdowns—showcased his ability to handle high-stakes games.
However, questions about his consistency and decision-making have some fans wondering if it’s time for a fresh start under center.
The Rise of Arch Manning
On the other side of the debate is Arch Manning, the freshman phenom and scion of football royalty. As the nephew of Peyton and Eli Manning, Arch arrived in Austin with immense hype and sky-high expectations. Though he spent most of the 2024 season as a backup, his talent is undeniable.
Manning’s natural athleticism, quick decision-making, and strong arm have impressed both coaches and teammates during practices. Fans are eager to see what he can do in live game situations. His ability to inject new energy into the offense could be exactly what the Longhorns need to take the next step.
What’s at Stake for the Longhorns
The quarterback decision is more than just a battle for the starting job—it’s a defining moment for the future of Texas football. Choosing Ewers would signal trust in a seasoned leader to deliver immediate results, while opting for Manning could mark the beginning of a new era for the program.
Steve Sarkisian’s decision will also have recruiting implications. A misstep could impact the Longhorns’ ability to attract top talent in the coming years. Balancing loyalty to Ewers with the undeniable potential of Manning is no easy task.
The Fans’ Perspective
Social media has been abuzz with Longhorns fans weighing in on the debate. Some are firmly in Ewers’ camp, arguing that his experience and leadership are irreplaceable. Others are calling for Manning to take over, believing his ceiling is higher and that he represents the future of the program.
What’s Next?
Spring practice will likely provide some clarity, as both quarterbacks will have the opportunity to compete head-to-head. Sarkisian’s choice could be influenced by factors like team chemistry, offensive strategy, and performance in preseason scrimmages.
Regardless of who takes the first snap in 2025, one thing is certain: the Longhorns’ quarterback situation is a good problem to have. With two elite talents vying for the job, Texas fans can rest assured that the program is in capable hands.
Will it be the experienced Ewers or the electrifying Manning? Longhorn Nation awaits the answer with bated breath.
