Trading Deebo Samuel is a Win for the 49ers
The San Francisco 49ers are on the cusp of another Super Bowl run, but difficult decisions must be made to ensure long-term success. One such decision? Trading Deebo Samuel. While it may seem counterintuitive to move on from one of the league’s most dynamic playmakers, dealing Samuel could be the best move for San Francisco’s future.
Deebo’s Value Has Peaked
Samuel’s best season came in 2021 when he recorded 1,405 receiving yards, 365 rushing yards, and 14 total touchdowns. He was a game-changing force, redefining the “wide back” position in Kyle Shanahan’s offense. However, since then, injuries and inconsistent production have limited his impact. In 2023, Samuel posted solid numbers but was often overshadowed by the emergence of Brandon Aiyuk and the ever-reliable Christian McCaffrey.
Given his versatile skill set, Samuel still holds tremendous value on the trade market. Teams seeking an explosive offensive weapon would be willing to pay a premium, especially with the rising cost of elite receivers. The 49ers could capitalize on this and fetch valuable draft capital or even a difference-making player in return.
Financial Flexibility
The 49ers have significant financial commitments to key players like McCaffrey, Trent Williams, and Fred Warner. Additionally, extending quarterback Brock Purdy and wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk will soon become top priorities. Samuel carries a hefty contract, having signed a three-year, $71.5 million extension in 2022. Moving him would create salary cap flexibility and allow San Francisco to retain other key pieces of their championship-caliber roster.
Aiyuk is the Future
Brandon Aiyuk has emerged as the 49ers’ best pure receiver. He possesses elite route-running ability, reliable hands, and explosive after-the-catch skills. In 2023, Aiyuk led the team in receiving yards and consistently delivered in high-pressure situations. If the 49ers must choose between Samuel and Aiyuk due to financial constraints, Aiyuk is the logical choice for the long haul.
The Offense Can Survive Without Deebo
One of the biggest arguments against trading Samuel is his unique playmaking ability. However, the 49ers’ offense is structured in a way that minimizes the impact of losing any one player. Christian McCaffrey, George Kittle, and Aiyuk can shoulder the load, while Shanahan’s scheme consistently generates opportunities for lesser-known players to thrive. The 49ers could also use draft capital from a Samuel trade to add depth at receiver or bolster other positions of need.
Conclusion
While Deebo Samuel has been an electrifying weapon for the 49ers, moving on from him now would be a proactive step toward maintaining roster balance and financial stability. By trading Samuel at peak value, San Francisco can invest in its future while remaining a legitimate Super Bowl contender. It may be an unpopular decision among fans, but in the long run, it could be the smartest move the 49ers make this offseason.
