Packers Fans Debate: Who Is the Best QB in Green Bay History?
The Green Bay Packers have one of the richest histories in the NFL, especially when it comes to legendary quarterbacks.
From Super Bowl champions to record-setting passers, the Packers’ QB legacy is filled with greatness. But the big question remains: Who is the greatest Packers quarterback of all time?
Some fans argue for Bart Starr, the ultimate leader who brought Green Bay its first two Super Bowl titles.
Others believe Brett Favre deserves the crown, thanks to his gunslinging style and unforgettable performances.And, of course, many stand by Aaron Rodgers, the precision passer who dominated the 2010s and brought home another Lombardi Trophy.
Let’s break down the top contenders and let YOU decide who reigns supreme!
Bart Starr (1956-1971) – The Ultimate Winner
✅ Super Bowl Wins: 2 (Super Bowl I & II)
✅ NFL Championships: 5 (before the Super Bowl era)
✅ Legacy: The face of Vince Lombardi’s dynasty
Bart Starr wasn’t just a quarterback; he was a leader. He played during an era where passing wasn’t as dominant, but he still led the Packers to five NFL championships and won the first two Super Bowls in history. His legendary “Ice Bowl” quarterback sneak in 1967 is still one of the most iconic plays in NFL history.
Why Fans Love Him:
Clutch Performer – Starr had a 9-1 playoff record!
True Leader – He defined the Lombardi era.
Super Bowl MVP – He won back-to-back MVPs in the first two Super Bowls.
Brett Favre (1992-2007) – The Gunslinger
✅ Super Bowl Wins: 1 (Super Bowl XXXI)
✅ NFL MVP Awards: 3 (1995-1997)
✅ Legacy: Most entertaining QB in Packers history
Favre was a warrior on the field. He played 297 consecutive games (321 including playoffs), the longest streak by a quarterback in NFL history. With his fearless style, he threw for 508 career touchdowns and brought home a Super Bowl win in the ’90s, revitalizing the franchise. However, his high-risk, high-reward playstyle led to a record 336 interceptions.
Why Fans Love Him:
Tough as Nails – Played through injuries and never quit.
Electrifying to Watch – Made impossible plays look easy.
Revived the Packers – Brought Green Bay back to the top.
Aaron Rodgers (2005-2022) – The Precision Passer
✅ Super Bowl Wins: 1 (Super Bowl XLV)
✅ NFL MVP Awards: 4 (2011, 2014, 2020, 2021)
✅ Legacy: Most efficient QB in Packers history
Rodgers took the Favre legacy and refined it to perfection. With an incredible touchdown-to-interception ratio, he was the most efficient QB in Packers history. His Hail Mary passes, pinpoint accuracy, and ability to extend plays made him one of the best of his generation.
Why Fans Love Him:
Deadly Accurate – One of the best TD-to-INT ratios ever.
Cool Under Pressure – Master of comebacks and game-winning drives.
Brought Another Lombardi – Led the Packers to victory in Super Bowl XLV.
Who Is the Greatest? YOU Decide!
Each of these quarterbacks defined their era. Starr built the foundation, Favre brought excitement, and Rodgers perfected efficiency.
So, Packers fans, who gets your vote?
Drop a comment below and let the debate begin!
