Superman Colourist Gabe Eltaeb Resigns Over Motto Change Controversy
The comic book world was rocked by controversy after DC Comics announced a change to Superman’s iconic motto. Long defined by the phrase “Truth, Justice, and the American Way,” the Man of Steel now fights for “Truth, Justice, and a Better Tomorrow.”
This shift has sparked debate among fans and industry insiders, with many questioning what the change signifies for the character’s legacy. Among those deeply affected is Gabe Eltaeb, a veteran comic book colourist, who recently announced his resignation in protest.
Eltaeb, known for his work on Superman and other iconic heroes, expressed his discontent during a live stream with YouTuber Ethan Van Sciver. He criticized DC’s decision, calling it a departure from Superman’s roots.
“What really made me lose my mind was when they changed the motto,” Eltaeb said. “I’m tired of this nonsense; I’m tired of them ruining these characters.”
The Motto Controversy
Superman’s motto, introduced in the 1940s, has long symbolized the character’s association with American ideals. Changing it to “Truth, Justice, and a Better Tomorrow” marks an effort by DC Comics to make Superman’s mission more universal and inclusive, aligning with global audiences and contemporary values.
DC publisher Jim Lee described the new motto as reflective of Superman’s role as “a hero for everyone.”
However, critics like Eltaeb argue that the change erases a significant part of Superman’s identity. For Eltaeb, the decision was emblematic of what he sees as a broader trend of cultural and political shifts in the comic book industry that prioritize modern messaging over classic storytelling.
Resignation and Backlash
Eltaeb’s resignation underscores the larger tensions within the comic book community, where debates over creative direction and cultural values have become increasingly heated. While many fans and creators support DC’s efforts to modernize, others feel alienated by what they see as a departure from tradition.
On social media, reactions to Eltaeb’s decision were mixed. Supporters praised his courage to stand by his principles, while detractors accused him of overreacting to a creative choice meant to expand Superman’s appeal.
The Future of Superman
DC’s decision to update Superman’s motto is part of a broader rebranding strategy aimed at ensuring the character remains relevant in an evolving world.
The move reflects a shift in how legacy characters are positioned to address global audiences, but it also raises questions about balancing innovation with tradition.
Eltaeb’s departure serves as a reminder of how deeply fans and creators connect with these characters. For some, Superman is more than a fictional hero—he represents timeless ideals rooted in a specific cultural context. As the comic book industry continues to evolve, finding a balance between honoring the past and embracing the future will remain a challenge.
Superman’s story, and the debates it inspires, reflects the enduring power of storytelling to shape and reflect cultural values. While his motto may have changed, the essence of his mission—to inspire hope and fight for justice—remains a cornerstone of his legacy.
